We make wood-decay mushroom extracts in two forms: dissolved in honey from South Bohemia, or poured into a plant-based capsule. The mushrooms come from the same extracts in both cases — what differs is how concentrated a single dose is, the way it is measured out, the taste, the storage and who each form suits. This is a comparison of precisely those properties, the ones you can read off the label yourself and check at home on your kitchen worktop.
What is in a single dose
Extract in honey is honey first and foremost. In EXTRA in honey, 100 g of the product is made up of 95 g of honey and 5 g of mushroom extracts. The recommended daily dose is 9 g, roughly one teaspoon, and it contains 180 mg of reishi extract, 54 mg of hericium, 54 mg of chaga, 49.5 mg of almond mushroom, 40.5 mg of maitake, 36 mg of cordyceps and 36 mg of shiitake — 450 mg of mushroom extracts in all. Nine grams per dose also means that a nine-hundred-gram jar will see you through a hundred days.
Premium capsules take the opposite route — no carrier, just the extract. One capsule holds 500 mg of concentrated extract. In REISHI it is an extract with a guaranteed content of 50 % polysaccharides and 10 % triterpenes, in CORDYCEPS 50 % polysaccharides and 25 % beta-glucans, and in EXTA a blend of six kinds of mushroom with a guaranteed content of 50 % polysaccharides. A whole pack of 60 capsules weighs 30 grams net.
One practical point follows from this: the two forms cannot be compared gram for gram, only dose for dose. And do watch the composition — EXTRA in honey has seven kinds of mushroom including cordyceps, whereas EXTA capsules have six. Among the capsules, cordyceps has a separate product of its own, so anyone who wants the same thing in capsules as in the honey EXTRA takes EXTA and CORDYCEPS side by side.
A spoon or a capsule: how the dose is measured out
A spoon is convenient, but it is not a measuring cap. Nine grams of honey is a heaped teaspoon, and there will always be some difference between two spoonfuls — in practice that does not matter, but anyone who wants it accounted for to a tenth of a gram will not get that from a spoon. The upside of that imprecision is the mirror image: a honey dose can easily be split into two halves across the day, or you can start with a smaller amount.
A capsule, by contrast, seals the dose firmly. The filling is measured to the sort of tolerance that is standard in pharmaceutical practice too — with fillings above 300 mg the limit worked to is ±7.5 %. The variations come from the nature of natural raw materials and have no bearing on quality or safety, but it is worth knowing that “500 mg” is a target figure, not an absolute constant.
Nor is the dose always one capsule. REISHI, EXTA and CORDYCEPS have a daily dose of one capsule, so a pack of 60 lasts two months. TREMELLA GLOW and HAIR BEAUTY have a dose of two capsules a day — a pack of the same size therefore covers one month. When comparing packs it pays to look at the number of doses, not the number of capsules.
Taste, and how to get it down
The honey form tastes of honey — sweet, with a sweetish earthy echo of the extracts. You can eat it off the spoon, spread it on bread, stir it into yoghurt or dissolve it in tea; with tea the temperature should be 40 °C at most. For the children's version, IMUNO – JUNIOR, the dose is 7 g, and thanks to its pleasant taste the product is intended for children from 3 years of age as well as for adults.
A capsule has no taste at all. The shell is swallowed with plenty of water, and according to the product description this form is meant for exactly those people who prefer simple taking without the taste of honey. If honey or mushrooms do not suit your palate, that is the main reason to go for capsules.
What is in a capsule besides the extract
Nothing extra. The shell is made of hydroxypropyl methylcellulose of plant origin (HPMC), with no animal gelatine, and the filling contains neither fillers nor preservatives. That makes the capsules suitable for vegans too, and for people who cannot tolerate ordinary gelatine products; HAIR BEAUTY is additionally free from gluten, lactose, colourings and artificial preservatives.
The honey form needs no shell at all, because the carrier is itself a food. At the same time, though, it is a food of animal origin — for a vegan the honey version is not an option, whatever may be dissolved in it.
Storage and travelling
Honey is kept somewhere dry and dark at room temperature; once opened it should be used up within four months. Capsules are stored dry at room temperature up to 25 °C and in the original undamaged packaging. So neither form needs a fridge — that is a common misconception; honey in the fridge will in fact set hard faster.
The difference lies in weight and convenience. A nine-hundred-gram jar of honey is glass, weighs almost a kilo and needs a spoon to go with it, so for a week away it is impractical luggage; at home it lasts a hundred days and is the best-value size. A tub of 60 capsules holds 30 g net, fits in a trouser pocket and cannot spill. That is why the capsule descriptions say explicitly that they suit people who travel often.
Who each form does not suit
- Allergy to honey or bee products — the honey form is out of the question, capsules are fine.
- Vegans — the same case in reverse: a plant-based capsule yes, honey no.
- Children — here the limits differ by product, not by form. IMUNO – JUNIOR in honey is intended for children from 3 years of age. EXTRA, VITAL, OPTIMAL and PREMIUM in honey, along with REISHI, EXTA and CORDYCEPS capsules, are not intended for children under 3. POWER in honey and BAMBOO in honey have a limit of 12 years, MENO in honey and TREMELLA GLOW capsules are not intended for children at all, and with HAIR BEAUTY no age limit is given. With the youngest children there is also the matter of swallowing a capsule, which makes the honey form the more practical choice for them.
- Pregnant and breastfeeding women — neither form is intended for them.
- Anyone on medication or with health problems — with both forms, taking them needs to be discussed with your doctor.
The comparison in one place
| Form | One daily dose | Taste | Storage | Not an option for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Extract in honey | 9 g, about 1 teaspoon (IMUNO – JUNIOR 7 g) | sweet, honeyed | somewhere dry and dark at room temperature, within 4 months of opening | allergy to bee products, vegans |
| Premium capsules | 1 capsule = 500 mg of extract (TREMELLA GLOW and HAIR BEAUTY 2 capsules) | no taste | dry, up to 25 °C, in the original undamaged packaging | anyone who dislikes swallowing capsules, small children |
Price per dose, not per jar
Because the two forms differ in the size of the dose as well as the size of the pack, comparing the price per pack tells you nothing. That is why every product shows the price per daily dose right next to its price, recalculated for whichever currency you have chosen. It is the one figure that can honestly be compared between honey and capsules — and with the large 900 g packs it works out markedly better per dose than with the two-hundred-gram jars.
How to choose
- If you want a form you can take with your morning coffee, spread on bread or give to the children, and the sweet taste does not bother you — go for extract in honey, ideally the large pack.
- If you travel often and want a fixed dose, a clean composition with no carrier and no taste — go for premium capsules.
- If you are interested in one particular mushroom on its own rather than a blend — only the capsules can do that (REISHI, CORDYCEPS).
- The two forms can be combined, honey at home and capsules on the road, for instance. It is just that each product's own recommended dosage has to be respected, and doses must not be added up beyond the recommended amount.
You will find the whole range in both forms in our product listing. A food supplement is no substitute for a varied and balanced diet or a healthy lifestyle; do not exceed the recommended daily dose and keep out of the reach of children.