Why Does Flu Hit Us Hardest in Winter? And How Does It Arise?

It arrives at the same time every year, and every year slightly differently. Flu is not a “winter bug” that turns up by chance — it is a virus that makes perfect use of the physics of winter air and of our own habits. Once you grasp how it travels and why winter suits it so well, it stops looking like a coincidence.

Let us take it apart simply, clearly, and with a few things you have probably never heard.

What flu is and how many of them there actually are

Flu is a viral illness of the airways caused by influenza viruses. There is not just one of them:

  • Influenza A — the one that produces the biggest waves. It has a natural reservoir in waterfowl and is able to cross between species. It is type A that lies behind every pandemic of the 20th century.
  • Influenza B — it circulates practically only among people, mutates more slowly and has no animal reservoir.
  • Influenza C — widespread but inconspicuous. Most people go through it in childhood without ever knowing.
  • Influenza D — discovered in 2011 in pigs and cattle. So far it has not been confirmed as common in humans.

Mysterious labels such as H1N1 or H3N2 are not laboratory codes but a description of the surface of the virus. H stands for haemagglutinin, the protein the virus uses to attach itself to a cell of the mucous membrane. N stands for neuraminidase, which it uses to cut its way back out again. Eighteen haemagglutinins are known and eleven neuraminidases — and the combination of those two numbers gives the virus its name.

Why flu wears a different face every year

The hereditary information of flu is not DNA but RNA divided into eight separate segments. And this is where the remarkable part begins.

The enzyme the virus uses to copy its RNA has no proofreading. Whereas a cell checks the transcript afterwards and corrects mistakes, flu makes mistakes and keeps them. Every round of replication therefore turns out slightly different offspring and the surface of the virus gradually changes — the technical term for this is antigenic drift. That is why last year's flu is partly unfamiliar to the body, and why the composition of vaccines is reconsidered every year; the World Health Organization does so twice a year, separately for the northern and for the southern hemisphere.

The second scenario is worse. When two different flu viruses meet inside one cell, they can shuffle those eight segments between them like cards in a pack. What emerges is a virus with a completely new surface, one that has never existed before — that is antigenic shift, and it is behind the appearance of pandemic strains. The ideal place for such a meeting is a host that both human and avian viruses can infect; that is why flu in pigs and poultry is watched so closely.

A few figures to frame it

  • According to the World Health Organization, 5–10 % of adults and up to 30 % of children catch flu each year.
  • Worldwide it leads to 3–5 million severe cases a year.
  • In Europe, depending on the season, 15,000–70,000 deaths are attributed to flu, most often among people over 65.
  • A single sneeze releases tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of droplets into the air, ranging from thousandths of a millimetre to fractions of a millimetre.

How the virus gets from one person to another

Flu has no legs and no movement of its own. It needs a means of transport, and it has three:

  • Large droplets — they fly out with a cough or a sneeze, they are heavy and they fall to the floor within a metre or two. This is the route people picture first.
  • Aerosol — microscopic particles, produced even by ordinary speaking and breathing. They are so light that in the still air of a room they stay up for tens of minutes to hours. That is precisely why you can catch it in a room the ill person left long ago.
  • Contact transmission — the virus survives in an infectious state for a while on a door handle, a grab rail or a phone; from your hand it then gets inside when you touch your eyes, nose or lips. People touch their face several times a minute without noticing.

And one more thing that comes as a surprise: an infected person usually spreads the virus a day before they start feeling unwell. At the point when they feel perfectly fine, they are already at their most infectious.

Why winter in particular? Dry air is what decides it

It is not the cold as such but how much moisture the air can carry. Cold air holds far less water than warm air, and when we breathe it in from outdoors and warm it up to twenty degrees indoors, its relative humidity drops far below comfortable values. In a heated flat it commonly reaches 20–30 %.

What does that do to a droplet that flies out of a mouth?

  • In dry air the water evaporates out of it, it shrinks, it grows lighter — and instead of falling, it stays afloat. Both its reach and the time it spends in the air are considerably extended.
  • In humid air the droplet keeps its water, it is heavy and it settles to the floor. That is why flu follows a different annual pattern in the tropics than it does here.
  • Low temperature firms up the envelope of the virus. Flu is an enveloped virus — it has a fatty membrane, and in the cold that membrane is less permeable, so the virus stays functional for longer outside the body.
  • Winter lacks ultraviolet light. The sun is low, the day is short, and there is only a fraction of the UV radiation that damages the virus on surfaces and in aerosol.

Behaviour is added to the physics. In winter we spend many times more of our time indoors — in offices, schools, public transport and shops. Closed windows, plenty of people and hours of the same air are ideal conditions for aerosol. So it is not that winter weakens the person; winter improves the conditions for the virus.

The nose plays its part too. Cold, dry air slows the movement of the cilia on the nasal lining, which otherwise clear dirt and particles steadily outwards. When their progress slows down, the virus has more time on the mucous membrane.

How flu comes about — step by step

  • You breathe in aerosol, on a tram or in a meeting room, say.
  • With its haemagglutinin the virus attaches to a cell lining the nose or throat, and the cell draws the virus inside of its own accord.
  • The virus hands the cell its RNA, and the cell starts making parts for the virus instead of its own proteins — like a hacker who takes over someone else's computer and sets it to work for himself.
  • Within a few hours, thousands of new particles are released from a single infected cell and head for the cells next door.
  • The body recognises the foreign RNA and sounds the alarm. Only then do the troubles we associate with flu begin.

Fever and aching muscles are not the work of the virus

What a person feels during flu is not caused by the virus but by the response of their own body. The infected cells release signalling substances that reach the brain and, in the hypothalamus, reset the body's thermostat to a higher value. The body then finds that it is “below temperature” and starts to catch up — by shivering its muscles. Hence the chills and shaking as the fever rises: feeling cold at 39 degrees is merely the gap between the actual temperature and the newly set target.

The same signalling substances explain the rest of it. Aching joints and muscles, exhaustion, loss of appetite and the need to lie down are all part of the same response — the body is insisting on rest so that it can put its energy elsewhere.

Flu or a common cold?

People draw little distinction between the two, but biologically these are different viruses and a different course.

FluCommon cold
Onsetsudden; people can often name the hourgradual, a day or two
Temperatureusually highas a rule none or mild
Aching muscles and jointstypical and markedrarely
Runny nose and sneezingrather on the marginsthe main sign
Exhaustionsevere, lingers after the rest has passedmild

The common cold is caused by more than two hundred different viruses, most often rhinoviruses. We never build a lasting defence against them simply because there are too many.

Why the peak comes in January and February

The flu season in Europe runs roughly from October to May, but the peak most often falls in January and February. Everything comes together at that time: the driest indoor air, the shortest day, the least UV radiation, children going back to school after Christmas, and groups of people being shuffled together again after the holidays.

What flu does not get on with in a room

From the way the virus travels there follows a fairly concrete list. There are no miracles in it; it is physics:

  • Short bursts of airing. Opening a window wide for five minutes exchanges the air, aerosol included, and the walls do not cool down. A window left permanently ajar, by contrast, does not exchange the air at all; it only chills it.
  • Humidity of 40–60 %. Damper air shortens the time particles stay afloat and lets the lining of the nose do its job.
  • Soap and water. The fatty membrane of the virus falls apart in soapy water — washing your hands is not a ritual, it is chemistry. Twenty to thirty seconds, including between the fingers.
  • Hands away from the face. The shortest way in for the virus is not through the air but via your own finger.
  • Sleep. The cheapest thing on the list, and the first one we cut back in winter.

So flu is no accident of winter. It is a virus that mutates faster than the body can remember it, travels in air we have dried out ourselves, and does best in a room nobody airs. The strongest tool we have against it is knowing how it behaves — and arranging our winter accordingly.