Betulinic acid and curcumin: two remarkable substances from nature

What do birch bark and golden turmeric have in common? At first sight, almost nothing. One comes from a tree growing in European woodland, the other from a tropical plant that is an inseparable part of Asian culture. And yet they do share something – both hold natural compounds that have become a subject of modern scientific research.

Let us get to know betulinic acid and curcumin, two chemically quite different substances with a remarkable origin.

Betulinic acid: a rare compound hidden in the birch

The birch is one of the best-known trees of the European countryside. Its distinctive white bark contains a whole range of natural substances, among them betulin and betulinic acid.

It is betulin that lies behind that whiteness. It is a white crystalline substance which, according to the specialist literature, makes up roughly 10 to 30% of the dry matter of birch bark – hence the colour that everyone associates with the birch. Betulin was isolated as long ago as 1788 and is among the oldest described plant compounds of any kind.

Betulinic acid belongs to the pentacyclic triterpenoids, a group of organic compounds that occur naturally throughout the plant kingdom. It differs from betulin by a single change in its structure: at the edge of the molecule it carries a carboxyl group in place of an alcohol group. A small difference on paper, but altogether different chemistry.

Triterpenoids of this kind are found in dozens of plant species. What makes the birch interesting among them is above all the sheer concentration in its bark, and the fact that there is plenty of that bark in the timber industry – elsewhere the same substance would have to be won from a far poorer source.

Chemists have had their eye on the molecule for several decades now, and that is because of the way it is built: the pentacyclic skeleton is rigid and carries oxygen-bearing groups at both ends, so it can be altered in a targeted way. A whole series of derivatives has been described as a result – most often by altering that very carboxyl group, or the hydroxyl at the opposite end of the molecule.

Why is highly pure betulinic acid so costly?

Obtaining betulinic acid in high purity is a technologically demanding process. Processing birch bark is not enough on its own. The compound you are after has to be separated from the other natural substances present and then purified over and over again.

And there is one more thing to add to that. While there is a good deal of betulin in the bark, there is considerably less betulinic acid in it. In practice, therefore, betulin is usually isolated first and only then converted by chemical means – by oxidation – into betulinic acid. Every such step costs something and lowers the yield a little further.

Modern extraction and purification methods make it possible to obtain betulinic acid with a purity of up to 98%. In that case we are talking about a highly pure triterpenoid compound, not an ordinary crude plant extract.

It is precisely the intricacy of the isolation, the purification and the analytical checking that can push production costs up substantially. The final price depends on the technology used, on the yield and on the purity required.

Curcumin: a golden pigment with a history thousands of years long

Turmeric (Curcuma longa) comes from the tropical regions of Asia. Its rhizome has been used for centuries as a spice, as a natural dye and as part of traditional cultural practices.

Interestingly, turmeric practically never reproduces by seed in nature – it is a sterile plant and is propagated by dividing the rhizomes. Every plant in a field is thus in effect a continuation of the one before it. The vast majority of world production comes from India.

Behind the characteristic yellow to orange colour of turmeric stands a group of natural pigments known as curcuminoids. The best known of them is curcumin, and alongside it the rhizome holds two related pigments. In the food industry this group of substances goes under the designation E100.

From the chemical point of view it is a polyphenol: two aromatic rings joined by a seven-carbon bridge. That bridge carries two ketone groups which are able to flip into the enol form and back again – and it is on this mobility that both the colour and the behaviour of the whole molecule depend.

Curcumin is also interesting for its physical and chemical properties. It dissolves very poorly in water, for instance, and its stability depends on the surroundings it finds itself in. It changes colour with the acidity around it as well – in alkaline conditions it shifts from yellow to reddish brown, which can even be put to use as a simple indicator.

From that follows the way curcumin is handled in practice. In acidic conditions it is reasonably stable, in neutral and alkaline ones it breaks down, and in the light it fades – which is why, as a dye, it suits fats, powders and acidic sauces rather than a watery solution left standing in the light.

What do the two substances have in common?

Although betulinic acid and curcumin come from different natural sources and belong to different chemical groups, several interesting features link them:

  • Both dissolve very poorly in water – they are lipophilic, so they are worked with in fat, in alcohol or in solid form, not in a watery solution.
  • Both have a well-described structure, yet they belong to entirely different chemical groups: betulinic acid is a triterpenoid, curcumin a polyphenol.
  • Both are obtained from a part of the plant that is otherwise waste or a spice – from bark left over in a timber works, and from a dried rhizome.
  • In neither case does the raw material hold the substance on its own: alongside betulinic acid the bark holds betulin and other triterpenoids, and alongside curcumin there are two related curcuminoids. The content is therefore determined chromatographically.
  • Isolating them and purifying them to a high purity calls for particular technological methods – and with both of them that is the expensive part.

It is interesting how such different natural sources can hold chemically complex compounds that open up further questions for modern science.

From traditional raw materials to modern laboratories

The history of the use of birch and turmeric reaches far back into the past. Present-day science, however, approaches their individual components in quite a different way from traditional cultures.

Thanks to modern analytical methods, high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) for example, specialists can identify specific chemical substances in the samples they study and determine how much of them is there.

Standardisation and purity control play an important part as well. They make it possible to describe the composition of the materials under study more precisely and to compare the results of individual laboratory analyses.

It is important, though, to distinguish between the results of laboratory experiments, research on animal models and clinical studies in humans. These levels of research yield different kinds of information and cannot simply be taken for one another.

Scientific research and health claims: two different things

Although betulinic acid and curcumin are both subjects of scientific research, no health claims have been approved in the European Union for betulinic acid as such or for curcumin as such that would allow their effects on health to be routinely stated in commercial communication about food supplements.

That distinction matters. A published scientific study does not in itself mean that its findings may be used as a health claim when presenting a food or a food supplement.

The assessment of health claims in the EU follows established rules, and among the things weighed up are the quality and the sufficiency of the scientific evidence.

Scientific research and legally permitted health claims are therefore two separate fields.

Nature still has surprises in store

Birch bark and turmeric are fine examples of just how varied the chemistry of the natural world is.

Although humankind has been making use of plants for thousands of years, modern analytical technology lets us learn about their composition in ever greater detail.

And with both substances it is the ratio that is most striking. Nature hands over the raw material almost for nothing – as bark that is left over at the sawmill anyway, and as a rhizome that is dried for use as a spice anyway. What comes afterwards is the expensive part: separating one compound from dozens of chemically similar ones, purifying it and proving by analysis that it really is that compound, and in what quantity.